I’ve put together a collection of recipes that use sourdough discard. If you’re a sourdough baker, you know how painful it is to throw away that hard earned yeasty goodness each time you have to feed the starter.
If you love to bake bread but haven’t delved into the world of sourdough yet, I encourage you to dive-in head first.
If you don’t have a sourdough starter yet, jump right in. I’ll teach you how to make a sourdough starter from scratch.
You can also read how I feed and maintain my sourdough starter to keep my starters (I have 3!) active.
When you add unfed sourdough discard to a recipe, it’s not there to add extra leavening since it’s not really active. If the sourdough starter is not a leavener, why is it in there?
The sourdough discard imparts an interesting texture and lovely complex flavor even if it’s not adding a big rise.
Try my Sourdough Discard recipes or create your own. Each cup of sourdough discard can replace 4 oz of flour and 4 oz of liquid in almost any recipe.
Since you’ve got your starter fed, peruse the entire list of My Best Sourdough Recipes. Have fun!
Sourdough Discard Recipes
Here are all of my best recipes that use sourdough discard in one collection. Peruse the photos and click to view the entire post and recipe. Have fun!
Sourdough Bundt Cake with Buttermilk Glaze is a perfect snack cake. The tangy-sweet buttermilk glaze forms an ultra-thin coating. A little sourdough discard transforms an ordinary cake into an extraordinary treat.
Sourdough Blondies! The perfect gooey blondie with a crackly crust is made even better with a dash of sourdough discard. These blondies have amazing butterscotch flavor.
The perfect fudgy brownie with a crackly top is made even better with a dash of sourdough discard. Can a brownie be both fudgy and airy at the same time? Yep!
Sourdough biscuits that are both fluffy and flaky. A little discard sourdough starter gives these biscuits a wonderful flavor.
A Perfect Pie Crust is a thing of beauty. The addition of a little sourdough discard adds an intriguing depth of flavor to a basic pie dough.
Super moist pumpkin bread has a wonderful background tang from "discard" sourdough starter. Fresh cranberries add another tangy pop to the flavor of the bread.
Start making Whole Grain Sourdough Waffles the night before and have hot fresh waffles for breakfast.
This classic buttermilk scone is given a little flavor boost with sourdough discard.
M J Williams
I’m new at using sourdough starter, but loving it very much. I am always looking for recipes to use the discard. Thank you very much for sharing. I’ll let you know how it turns out. I’m going to try the cinnamon rolls first.
Eileen Gray
It really is fun to work with sourdough. Hope you enjoy the cinnamon buns.
Michelle
Can you help me understand when sourdough becomes a discard? I have had my starter in the fridge and have kept it on the small side, feeding it once every week to two weeks. i believe the discard os what I pull off the original batch, however, I never seemed to have enough. I followed your recipe for feeding a starter and am keeping a double batch on the counter. can I use this in discard recipes even if it is active and bubbling? If not, what would you suggest in this senario? Id like to make something twice a week from my sourdough starter. Thanks for taking the time to put such good information out there!
Eileen Gray
Hi Michelle, yes the discard is what you pull off the original batch when you feed the starter. It’s kind of hard to explain, but if you have a cup of active and bubbling starter and add it to a recipe, that starter will continue to multiply and will be the catalyst for the rise of the baked item. If the stuff you pull off is sluggish (discard), that means there’s not a lot of active and live yeast in it. If you add the sluggish (discard) stuff to a recipe it will add flavor and texture, but not necessarily give significant rise to the baked item.
If you are baking 2x per week from your starter you don’t really need to have any discard. I find that if I feed my starter, leave it at room temp for a couple of hours to activate, then put it in the refrigerator it will be good to go for a couple of days. Take the starter out a day or two after feeding and it should still be active enough to use once it comes to room temp. Use what you need for the recipe, feed the base, leave at room temp for a few hours and then refrigerate. Just continue doing this 2x per week when you bake.
If you leave it at room temperature all the time, you will have some discard since it really needs to be fed every day. I know I’m not giving a concrete answer but there are sooooooo many variable when working with sourdough.
Kristin
Your explanation was really helpful! I was wondering how I can keep it alive if I don’t feed it everyday because of lack of use. Thank you’
Nici
You can keep it in the Fridge. As she said above: after you feed it and let it sit for a couple of hours, and then pop it in the fridge. Instructions I have found say leaving it alone for a week or so is fine, It needs air, so air-tight containter is not good. If it makes “hooch” where liquid separates from the solids, some say stir it back in, some say pour it out. The starter definitely needs to be fed if it has done that. I find a week in the fridge then it needs feeding. There are a lot of different opinions, and it can be confusing. I suggest start small (this can use a lot more flour than you realize), maybe make a couple of different batches and experiment with what works with your schedule. Poke around, some of the flour manufacturers have good advice, some bakers. This is a “live” entity and it needs tender love and care. Good luck!
Sarah
In February, my wife and I decided to cut back on our shopping budget AND eat more whole foods.. AS part of this, we decided to start making our own bread. This month, all of the local stores have sold out of yeast as people stockpile supplies for the apocalypse, so in order to keep making bread, we had to get a starter going. This is new for us, and we’re learning a lot. I came looking for ways to use the discard, and found your sourdough English muffin recipe, too. Your instructions are super clear and I appreciate the amount of science and how/why information you provide – the scientist in me thoroughly appreciates it!
Eileen Gray
Why thank you Sarah! I find sourdough baking infinitely fascinating.
Elissa
I second Sarah’s comment to the letter! Thank you Eileen! Baking bread and growing starter babies is helping so much! Your website is the perfect resource during these anxious times.
Eileen Gray
That’s so kind of you to say, Elissa. I find baking to be very therapeutic and relaxing. Baking bread is especially rewarding.
Ashley V
When I feed the starter, can I just split it in half instead of using the discard? Like, create two starts from one and continue feeding / maintaining both of them? I’m sure that sounds like double the work, but I’m fascinated by the whole concept and trying to experiment with it. Your videos and “how-to” guidance are the best!
Eileen Gray
Yes, you can split the starter into multiple starters. I actually maintain 3 starters. It’s handy when I want to bake multiple things in one day. Make sure to always maintain the 100% balance with equals weights of starter-flour-water.
Yoon
I just came across your website via Pinterest looking for discard recipes and read that keeping equal ratios of starter/flour/water is important! I haven’t been discarding anything, ended up with 2 active starters and one in the fridge, but have only been feeding equal parts water/flour, no discard,. The 2 starters seem to grow and bubble each time I feed it. And I didn’t wait until fridge starter warmed up and activated before placing back in the fridge. Have I killed anything!! Thank you for your clear directions and advice!
Eileen Gray
The purpose of discarding some of the starter is so that you don’t end up drowning in sourdough starter. There are different ways of feeding a starter, I use the 100% hydration ratio which means that each time you feed you use equal weights of starter-flour-water. I doubt you’ve killed your starter. As long as it’s getting fed it’s probably alive. Read through my post How to Maintain a Sourdough Starter and How to Keep a Small Sourdough Starter for more information.
Juliette Reiland
How do you maintain 100% hydration when feeding your starter without needing to change the jar each day? I’m keeping mine on the counter.
Eileen Gray
Do you mean just to keep the container clean? Since I use deli containers I will usually pour off the 4oz of starter into a clean container and add the flour and water to that. If you have one specific container that you like to use you can pour out all the starter, clean the container and then pour the 4 oz back into the container for feeding.
Andrea T
Hi Ashley. I started on the SD journey in February. I’ve baked for years and have written a cookbook too. I didn’t want to throw any starter away either, so the next best thing was to create a new jar. I have three starters going: John Dough, Jane Dough and Play Dough. I alternate who I use and even gave a small jar to my son-in-law to start his own journey. I finally got a hold of some rye flour (impossible to find these days) so I will be using Eileen’s recipe today. Good luck, Lot’s of fun.
Rebecca
What if I don’t have access to “filtered” water? Is tap water okay? Would I use bottled water? I’m in Japan and I don’t see anything labeled filtered water and I don’t read Japanese.
Eileen Gray
You can visit my post How to Make Sourdough Starter. I explain there that I use tap water for my starter.
Christina Messina
I guess it depends where you live, I’ve tried tapwater and filtered water and filtered water works way better because the chemicals used to treat the water in California. I also started one of my jars with pineapple juice which was unfiltered and organic but that was only the very first day then use filtered water after that I have two amazing starters and I’ve been able to share with many friends and neighbors during these trying times we’re all becoming bakers, thank you so much for your blog and taking the time to make These incredible recipes I have used a lot of them
Jackie
Can the discard be used prior to the starter becoming fully active (say on day 5 or 6), or only after the initial 7 – 10 day activation? So hard to just throw it away. Gave some 4 day old starter to a friend to continue to feed and activate but tough during social distancing to give away.
My first time experimenting with sourdough. Excited to try many of your recipes!
Eileen Gray
Honestly, I’ve been wondering this myself lately. I’ve never had to think about throwing away the discard before the current situation. I wouldn’t use the discard from the first few days of feeding when the smell is unpleasant and cheesy.
bela
just started making my starter day 2 today.yes yeast is no longer avaliable.. but i only have an air fryer.. i hope i can bake breads make scones in airfryer, Thanks,,,
Jo
I have sourdough starter stored in my refrigerator. For any of your recipes, which all look fabulous, that call for discard, does the discard need to come to room temperature first? Or can I spoon it out of the frig and weigh it and use it?
Thanks!
Eileen Gray
Generally you can use the cold discard, especially in the pie dough, scones and biscuits. If it needs to be room temp it will specify in the recipe. The only caveat is that if the discard is room temp you might get a little rise from the remaining yeast in the discard. Of course that depends how active it is that that point.
Michele Caldwell
Thank you so much for all the hints and help plus the recipes. I was using a well known duos sour dough book but no where was there any mention of discarding the excess sourdough.I was starting to have real concern over the amount of flour.Even other publications do not give any help with its use.Reading your sour dough discard has been a tremendous help. Michele from Mirboo North Victoria Australia
MaryCarol
Your sour dough rye bread is possibly the best rye I have ever tasted! Thank you!
Eileen Gray
Thanks! It’s a personal favorite of mine. I love anything rye. If you’re a rye fan, you might want to try my Rye Pie Crust.
MaryCarol
I tried your fudgy brownies with leftover starter. They came out an odd texture. Is it correct to use 1 cup of starter and 1 tablespoon of vanilla? The taste was good but they were crumbly.
Eileen Gray
Yes, that is correct. They are a little lighter than a regular brownie, but I wouldn’t call them crumbly. Was your starter still pretty active? Maybe the brownies got a little too much lift from the starter. I used sourdough discard that hadn’t been fed for about a week.