Tiramisu Ice Cream Cake is a no-bake, frozen version of everyone’s favorite Italian dessert. Layers of Savoiardi biscuits soaked in an espresso-Marsala syrup are layered with homemade Mascarpone Ice Cream for a luscious frozen dessert.
Whew! I’ve been making this recipe for a month and I’m finally ready to share it with you. Don’t worry, it’s not that it takes a month to make the recipe, in fact it’s fairly quick to make, it just took me a month of trying various versions of the recipe to get it just right.
I love Tiramisu, and I bet you do too. What’s not to love? Coffee-Marsala-soaked-biscuits are layered with creamy, airy Mascarpone cream filling. A hit of bitter cocoa on top is the perfect foil for all the creamy sweetness below. It’s a wonderful dessert.
Because it’s summer, and because there are plenty of traditional Tiramisu recipes available, I thought it would be nice to make an ice cream version of Tiramisu. I love any excuse to make (or eat) ice cream. I especially like to make ice cream with dairy products other than cream; for example, cream cheese, buttermilk, or creme fraiche.
As usual, the part of the recipe that I was most concerned about (the Mascarpone Ice Cream) turned out to be very simple to get just right, and the part of the recipe that should be simple (the lady fingers) was anything but.
For my first version of Tiramisu Ice Cream Cake I made an ice cream base using Mascarpone Cheese in place of heavy cream. I layered the fresh-from-the-churn ice cream with traditional Italian Lady Fingers, Savoiardi. The Savoiardi were dunked in a syrup made with coffee, sugar and Marsala Wine.
I brought the first version of the recipe to a family party. I just got a quick taste, but realized I’d used the wrong size pan (13″x 9″), so the layers of ice cream were too thin compared to the layers of Savoiardi.
For version 2 of the recipe I layered the same ingredients into a 9″x 9″ square pan. The size was perfect! But when we tasted the Tiramisu the next day I found that the lady fingers were icy and bland. Of course, all that water in the coffee was freezing solid and diluting the flavors.
When you make a frozen dessert, ice cream, sorbet, whatever, if the mix has too much water you’ll get an icy end-product. Sugar helps keep the mix from freezing solid, and so does alcohol. Because my original recipe just used cold coffee with a little sugar and Marsala, the liquid was freezing solid. I knew I had to reduce the amount of water significantly to get a better texture for the cake.
So I nixed the idea of using coffee and decided to use espresso powder instead. I started with a heavy syrup made from equal parts water and sugar and added a full 1/4 cup of instant espresso powder. I tripled the amount of Marsala in the syrup. If you tasted the syrup all by itself it would be too strong! Because flavors are muted in frozen foods, a stronger syrup is needed for a full-flavored frozen dessert.
That was the ticket. The lady fingers in the final recipe had a soft bite and good flavor. They were the perfect contrast to the creamy Mascarpone Ice Cream and bitter cocoa.
Watch this video to see how to make Tiramisu Ice Cream Cake!
You might also like: